In the 50s, a controversial comic book form that was known as EC comics, which influenced numerous writers and filmmakers in their wake, spit out stories that became almost an American Grimm’s fairytales.
Most of these stories are morality plays, which shows terrible people suffering fates even worse than what they perpetrated on others. These comic book stories were, of course the inspiration for George Romero and Stephen King‘s Creepshow film, and numerous anthology series and films in the following decades.
But one story that has inspired memes came out of Vault of Horror circa 1951, was All Through the House. This was an absolute Christmas time nightmare about a woman who decides to murder her husband and suffers terrifying consequences as a result.
The story was used as a segment for the 1973 Amicus film Tales from the Crypt starring Dynasty ingenue Joan Collins, and then later the 90’s HBO series Tales from the Crypt directed by Robert Zemeckis, starring Mary Ellen Trainor and Larry Drake.
Images from several of these comic book pages, and the film and TV episodes have lingered in the public memory to some degree for decades. This results from the story being extremely disturbing for its source material, and its subject matter.
Amicus was a British film studio that operated much in the same vein as hammer studios. Predominantly Gothic films starring the lakes of Ralph Richardson and Peter Cushing were their mainstay.
Tales from the crypt is a really good anthology film featuring some very dark material, drawn primarily from the comics I alluded to. Now, the connecting tissue in between the segments is far weaker than the stories themselves. But there’s a lot here to like.
The lead off is the Joan Collins take on all through the house, which is extremely unsettling as there is no actual score but Christmas music. She goes through the motions of murdering her husband, trying to cover it up and even thinks she’s safeguarded her house from an escaped lunatic in a Santa Claus outfit.
She turns out to be wrong.
This is 16 minutes of pure horror, and really does one of two things: primes the pump for whats to come, or offers a reason for you to think the rest of the film is a letdown. either way, the segment is terrific filmmaking and Freddy Francis (Dracula Has Risen From the Grave, and a list of cinematographer credits that would make most lighters jealous) is to be commended.
In 1989 All Through the House made the second episode of the premier season of HBO's Tales From the Crypt anthology series. This time its pedigree was as solid as it gets. Produced by Joel Silver and Richard Donner, music by legendary Alan Silvestri, cinematography from Dean Cundey, the chap who did the early John Carpenter masterpieces and went on to light some Spielberg work including Jurassic Park, and it’s helmed by director of Back to the Future and Forrest Gump's Robert Zemeckis. I mean holy shit.
Oh, and by the way, scripted by my one of my favorites, the guy responsible for Night of the Creeps and Monster Squad, Fred Dekker. A guy short-changed by Hollywood for some reason, as his talent exceeds that of many still working frequently in the business.
This take, in running with the series, contained a little more dark humor, more graphic violence, and a putridly intimidating Santa-murderer, played by Larry Drake (L.A. Law, Darkman). Mary Ellen Trainor as the mom, matches Joan Collins blow for blow.
So, my examination of this decades-long Christmas horror curio draws to a close.
Do I have a favorite.
I can't say. One is distinctly British, and the other has big budget American flash, so it's up to you. But the EC Comics tale still holds that morality tale punch, and final panel kick in the nuts that can't be exceeded.